top of page
Search

Workplace Surveillance and Its Limits in Canada

3d
7 min read

A lot of people go into work assuming that once they're on the clock, their employer can pretty much watch whatever it wants. That isn't entirely true, but in Canada it is a lot closer to the truth than most workers would probably like. Employers are expected to balance their operational needs against whatever privacy rights their employees have, and any monitoring is supposed to be reasonable, proportionate and tied to a legitimate business purpose. They also have to follow the existing rules on how employee data is kept, get consent in certain circumstances and give employees notice of how they are being monitored. When these disputes do end up in front of a court or a tribunal, the question almost always comes back to whether or not the monitoring was reasonable.


Which law actually applies depends a lot on who you work for. For federally regulated private sector employees, like those working at banks, airlines and telecommunications companies, monitoring is generally governed by the Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act, more commonly known as PIPEDA. In Ontario though, PIPEDA doesn't apply to the way provincially regulated employers handle their employees' personal information, so those workers are left relying on a fragmented network of other laws instead of one clear set of rules.


Employers usually have a reason in mind when they decide to start watching, whether that's suspected misconduct, protecting property or confidential information, keeping an eye on safety, or checking whether someone might be abusing their leave or benefits. The surveillance itself can take a lot of different forms, from regular or hidden video cameras, to monitoring work computers and email, GPS tracking, keeping tabs on social media, or even hiring a private investigator to follow an employee around, which is allowed as long as the methods are lawful and the scope of it is reasonable. It doesn't necessarily stop at the end of a shift either, and is often used to check up on employees who are off on benefits or injury and illness claims. There are limits though, and a lot of them come down to where the surveillance happens, since filming someone walking down a public street is treated very differently from filming them inside their own home or anywhere else they would reasonably expect some privacy.



Monitoring computers, email and other digital activity is legal as well, but how far an employer can go with it is a lot more nuanced. The leading case on this is R v Cole, a 2012 Supreme Court of Canada decision about a high school teacher in Sudbury, Ontario. A technician doing maintenance on his school-issued laptop came across inappropriate photos involving a student, and the school board ended up handing the laptop over to the police, who searched it without a warrant. Even though it was a criminal case, the question underneath it was really a workplace one, which was whether an employee can have any privacy in a device that belongs to their employer. The Court decided that because the teacher had been allowed to use the laptop for personal things, he still had a reasonable expectation of privacy in it, even if it was a smaller one than he would have had on his own computer, and that the police search without a warrant had violated his Charter rights. So just because your employer owns the device doesn't necessarily mean it owns everything on it.


An Example of Unreasonable Surveillance

It's a lot easier to understand what "unreasonable" looks like through an actual complaint, like PIPEDA Case Summary #2004-279, which was decided by the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada in July 2004. A former employee of an internet service provider believed the company had gone against PIPEDA when it installed web cameras to monitor its employees. In 2003, the company had put up two cameras, one pointed at the sales and marketing staff that could catch people coming, leaving or moving around, and another pointed at the technical support staff, where several people were in view at the same time. The company gave two reasons for having them, security and productivity. On the security side, it said employees had tripped the alarm on a number of occasions, and when that happened the security company would call a manager, who could check the cameras to make sure it was an employee in the building and not an intruder, even though there wasn't a camera pointed at the main entrance. It also mentioned occasional allegations of theft and harassment, although none had come up since the cameras were put in.



The productivity argument was even harder to justify, mostly because the company already had so many other ways of keeping track of its employees. It monitored its phone lines, tracking how long calls lasted, how many calls each person answered and the average time per call, and it recorded what kind of call each one was based on the buttons customers pressed to get to the right desk. Managers could also listen in on calls for training and quality assurance. On top of that it tracked email, swipe cards and internet traffic, did performance reviews twice a year and already had a progressive discipline policy in place. The company's explanation was that cameras were cheaper than hiring more managers, and that its margins were too small to take on the extra cost.


The Assistant Commissioner didn't find either argument very convincing. She started with section 3 of PIPEDA, which lays out that the purpose of the Act is to balance a person's right to privacy with an organization's need to collect information for reasonable purposes. On security, she found that unauthorized entry couldn't have been much of a concern if there was no camera on the entrance, and that the false alarms could be dealt with in a much less intrusive way, like having the employee call the security service themselves. As for theft and harassment, the company just hadn't offered enough evidence to show that something as intrusive as cameras was needed to deal with it. When it came to productivity, she didn't think the cameras added enough on top of everything the company was already doing to make up for the privacy they took away. She was also concerned that the cameras painted every employee with the same brush, including the ones who were outstanding and had never caused any problems, and that intruding on everyone's privacy because a few people might cause trouble wasn't a fair trade. In the end she found the balance had been "tipped too far in favour of the organization's needs" and recommended the company take the cameras down and confirm it in writing within 45 days.


Ontario's Unique Limits

Ontario has gone about things a bit differently. On April 11, 2022, the province's Working for Workers Act added new requirements to the Employment Standards Act, so that employers with 25 or more employees, counted on January 1 of each year, now need to have a written policy on electronic monitoring. The policy has to state whether or not the employer monitors its employees electronically, and if it does, it has to describe how it does it and in what circumstances, the purposes the information might be used for, the date the policy was prepared and the date of any changes. Employers also have to give their employees a copy, so at the very least people working at larger workplaces have a way of finding out whether their emails, keystrokes or locations are being tracked.


On paper it sounds like a step forward, but it doesn't actually do much to protect anyone. The ESA doesn't give employees a right not to be monitored by their employers, and it doesn't create any new privacy rights for them either. The policy is really more about transparency than anything else, which means an employer can still monitor its employees in pretty much whatever way it wants, as long as it writes it down and lets them know.


Where the Law Should Go

Right now, Canada's privacy laws work in two layers, with PIPEDA at the federal level and then province-specific laws underneath it that range from general reasonableness standards to mandatory written disclosure policies like Ontario's. Alberta, British Columbia and Quebec each have their own private sector privacy laws that the federal government has recognized as substantially similar to PIPEDA, but other provinces are left with a lot less. Compared to the European Union, Canada's protections are pretty weak. In the EU, privacy is treated as a fundamental right under the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and the EU's Charter of Fundamental Rights, and any use of employee monitoring software has to be justified under both privacy and labour laws. Transparency is at the centre of their regulations, and in some countries certain kinds of surveillance, like monitoring screen contents and keystrokes, actually require the employee's consent. In countries like Germany, companies with a works council, which is an elected group of a company's own employees that votes on decisions and protects workers' rights, often need the council's approval before they can bring in new monitoring measures. Because the standard companies are held to is so much higher, it's pretty common in Europe for monitoring to be found to violate employees' privacy, even when the same thing would probably pass in Canada without much trouble.



This is already playing out in Canada. In June 2026, Reuters reported that TD Bank told members of its financial crimes and risk management team that it would start using WorkiQ, software its maker markets as "employee and wellbeing intelligence," to track the time they spend on browsers, chat and meeting apps. TD called it standard practice across the industry, and an internal FAQ described it as a way for managers to get back some of the visibility they lost when people started working remotely. TD is a bank, so it falls under PIPEDA, the same law that was used in the web camera case, and yet the legal experts Reuters spoke to said Canadian employees still have very few protections against this kind of monitoring. The web camera case shows that the reasonableness standard can work, but only when someone actually complains and a regulator decides to step in. As monitoring gets cheaper and harder to notice, workers are going to need a real say in how they're being watched, and not just a policy letting them know that it's happening.


Works Cited

Balu, N. (2026, June 25). Canadian workers have few protections against workplace surveillance as TD starts monitoring. Reuters. https://www.reuters.com/business/world-at-work/canadian-workers-have-few-protections-against-workplace-surveillance-td-starts-2026-06-25/


E-Monitor Editorial Team. (2026, April 1). Employee monitoring laws in Canada: PIPEDA, provincial privacy & Ontario AI policy guide. E-Monitor. https://www.employee-monitoring.net/compliance/employee-monitoring-laws-canada


Employment Standards Act, 2000, S.O. 2000, c. 41, Part XI.1 (Written Policy on Electronic Monitoring). https://www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/00e41


Khrystenko, V. (2026, February 3). 12 most asked questions on EU employee monitoring laws (2026 edition). WorkTime. https://www.worktime.com/blog/legal-aspects/12-most-asked-questions-on-eu-employee-monitoring-laws


Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada. (2004, July 26). PIPEDA Case Summary #2004-279: Surveillance of employees at work. Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada. https://www.priv.gc.ca/en/opc-actions-and-decisions/investigations/investigations-into-businesses/2004/pipeda-2004-279/


Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada. (2004, April 1; modified 2025, May 29). Privacy in the workplace. Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada. https://www.priv.gc.ca/en/privacy-topics/employers-and-employees/02_05_d_17/


Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act, S.C. 2000, c. 5. https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/P-8.6/


R. v. Cole, 2012 SCC 53, [2012] 3 S.C.R. 34.

 
 
 

Comments


© 2026 by QCLA. Powered and secured by Wix

QCLA logo
7sage-social-preview-3c2161df7e26e6c5ba1d745234613f1e-removebg-preview.png
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
bottom of page